PDF comments viewable directly in Wrike

@Tamkiko Hi there! Just want to make sure I understand, you want to be able to see comments added through the Adobe PDF viewed in Wrike?

Yes, I did a quick comparison to show exactly what's different from the PDF vs. in Wrike.

@Tamiko That's so helpful, thank you so much! 

I completely agree. My users are uploading PDF files with native comments and these are not visible within the Wrike view. You need to download to access the native comments, which isn't ideal. So it would be really helpful to have the ability to not only add comments etc directly within Wrike, but for Wrike to understand the native comments done prior to uploading

In our case highlighted areas was not marked at all

Is there a status on resolution to this?  I too am getting questions on why the comments cannot be seen unless you download the file.

@Jeanine Hey, welcome to the Community 🙂 I have no update at the moment, please make sure to upvote the original post by @Tamiko as this section works by a voting system. I'll get back here when I have news about this suggestion. 

Lisa Community Team at Wrike Wrike Product Manager Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Lisa Wrike Team member Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Would love for Wrike to find a solution to this...

Kat Rossos upvote the original post. I know more people want this but there are multiple "original" posts so unfortunately all the people that want it isn't reflected in the upvotes of this particular "original" post. The reviews we do get messed up all the time because we have to rely on people using the 'edit' function even when just reviewing and hoping their system is setup correctly to open in Acrobat, not chrome. 

Hi Kat Rossos, welcome to the Community, and thank you for supporting this idea. Please do add your upvote as Jeanine Lore suggested - it helps our team understand the popularity of a suggestion👍🏼

It's been 5 years now during which several users have been asking for this function which is quite obviously extremely useful for proper collaboration. But it seems Wrike could not react on that during half a decade. - Is there any chance at all for an implementation of such a function? How many upvotes in how many years are required? Or should we rather look for a more effective solution for our team? 

Hi Rolf Schröder, thanks a lot for sharing your feedback. I understand it may be disappointing to see some of the suggestions, especially ones created a while back, not developed in Wrike. That's why I'd like to share some more info on how this forum works: it's based on votes and statuses, and at the same time, Wrike can't guarantee that all or even most of the suggestions will be implemented. As much as our Product team would love to work on the majority of the great suggestions our users are sharing with us, it's just not possible. Having said all that, we still find all the feedback we're receiving extremely useful and that's why we have this forum and the above-mentioned processes. Our team strives to dedicate some of its resources to customer-generated suggestions. For example, you can find some of the suggestions released last year that were Community-generated in this post. I hope this will give you a little bit more context around how we work with feedback from Community. Please let me know if there's anything I can help you with.

Lisa Community Team at Wrike Wrike Product Manager Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Lisa Wrike Team member Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Thanks for your reply, Lisa.  I know about Wrike's advantages, but after all, for me and many of my colleagues it is just a tool - not more, not less: We need it to work as efficiently as possible, but only a minority of us can take the time for participating in the improvement process. Thus, counting the upvotes for an original message written recently or long ago by some other slightly frustrated users appears to me as a rather vague method of determining the general users' practical needs. 
From my point of view, the facts are quite clear: 
- In many companies, pdf files have been established as a very important format for obtaining feedback on documents from colleagues. 
- Wrike defines itself as a collaboration tool. 
=> Thus, implementing the mentioned function seems to me to be a quite logical step. 
=> What would really help me (and probably a number of other users) is a clear statement if and under which conditions such a function would be applied. But I know that this is probably too much to ask for...

Thanks a lot for the additional feedback here Rolf Schröder! I'll pass it on to our team shortly 👍

On a related note, could you please let me know if you use Proofing at your company? It allows you to leave comments on files right inside Wrike. 

Lisa Community Team at Wrike Wrike Product Manager Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Lisa Wrike Team member Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Lisa, I know you asked Rolf Shroder the question regarding if he uses "Proofing" in Wrike. I know that we cannot as our labeling control change process requires Adobe Acrobat pdf redlines that must be kept and stored on our networks as part of traceability of change. 

Hi Lisa, yes, we partially use the commenting functions within Wrike. However, you probably know what it's like when different internal and external people are involved in proofing processes: Some have access to Wrike but others don't, or they prefer (or, as Jeanine Lore said, are even forced) to work with Adobe's (or another pdf reading tool's) commenting function.
=> Thus, my conclusion stays the same: A software like Wrike, with a clear focus on collaboration, should at least allow for reading comments made in a pdf reading tool.
(A full compatibility including an export function of comments made in Wrike would be amazing, but currently, me and a lot of others would already be very glad about a one way solution.) 

Lisa, another note to the is that even when using "edit" and opening\editing via Acrobat, we have problems since Wrike doesn't lock the file. We have multiple reviewers and have issues with people accidentally editing at the same time, not realizing anything except if they get an error when closing. Then they just version the file and overwrite what someone else may have done since they used "edit" and were working on the pdf.

Thank you for this additional feedback folks, it will be passed on to our team 👍

Lisa Community Team at Wrike Wrike Product Manager Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Lisa Wrike Team member Become a Wrike expert with Wrike Discover

Adding my vote to this. Along with support for hyperlinks within an uploaded PDF.

Right now stakeholders are confused that they can't see PDF comments left with Adobe Acrobat and I need to tell them to download a copy to see it.

Thank you for adding your vote and for your feedback Lilian Cheng! We'll keep you informed if there are any changes implemented 👍